BiasFairnessEthicscs.LG
Speciesist bias in AI -- How AI applications perpetuate discrimination and unfair outcomes against animals
Thilo Hagendorff, Leonie Bossert, Tse Yip Fai, Peter Singer
February 22, 2022
AI and Ethics
73 citations
4 influential
Key Takeaways
-
AI systems are amplifying existing discrimination against animals: The paper identifies "speciesist bias"—discrimination based on species—as a blind spot in AI fairness research. AI applications trained on datasets containing speciesist patterns actively perpetuate and normalize violence against animals, particularly farmed animals, rather than remaining neutral tools.
-
Multiple AI technologies are affected: Speciesist bias appears across diverse AI systems including image recognition, large language models, and recommender systems, suggesting this is a widespread problem rather than an isolated issue in one type of application.
-
Current fairness efforts are incomplete: While the AI community has made significant progress addressing biases against women, people of color, and minorities, these fairness frameworks systematically ignore discrimination against animals, leaving a major gap in responsible AI development.
-
AI choices have real-world consequences for animals: The paper emphasizes that AI systems significantly influence whether violence against animals increases or decreases in society, making decisions about training data and algorithm design consequential for animal welfare outcomes.
-
Mitigation requires deliberate action: The authors argue that addressing speciesist bias requires AI fairness frameworks to actively expand their scope and implement specific mitigation measures—it will not be resolved through current approaches alone.