EthicsFairnessExplainabilitycs.AI
Against Algorithmic Exploitation of Human Vulnerabilities
Inga Strümke, Marija Slavkovik, Clemens Stachl
January 12, 2023
arXiv.org
4 citations
1 influential
Key Takeaways
-
Recommender systems may inadvertently exploit human vulnerabilities: Machine learning models used for recommendations (movies, music, products) can unintentionally learn to identify and act on sensitive information about users' vulnerabilities such as depression, young age, or gambling addiction, even when this information was never explicitly provided to the system.
-
The problem is largely invisible: Because these vulnerabilities are learned as "latent representations" within AI models rather than explicitly programmed, companies and regulators may not realize when algorithmic systems are making decisions based on exploiting vulnerable states—making this a hidden form of potential manipulation.
-
Vulnerable groups may face discriminatory treatment: The paper emphasizes the need to detect whether AI models treat vulnerable populations differently than others, suggesting that current systems may be systematically disadvantaging people in susceptible states without transparency or accountability.
-
Explainability is essential for protection: The authors conclude that explainable AI methods are necessary to detect when vulnerability exploitation is occurring, implying that current "black box" AI systems cannot be adequately monitored for this harm and that transparency requirements should be part of responsible AI governance.
-
This issue requires legislative attention: The paper calls for awareness of vulnerability exploitation to be considered in AI legislation and ethics frameworks, suggesting that current regulations do not adequately address this specific form of algorithmic harm.