ExplainabilityTransparencyTrustworthinesscs.CE
Interpretable Classification of Levantine Ceramic Thin Sections via Neural Networks
Sara Capriotti, Alessio Devoto, Simone Scardapane, Silvano Mignardi, Laura Medeghini
June 13, 2025
Machine Learning: Science and Technology
1 citations
Key Takeaways
-
AI can accelerate archaeological analysis while maintaining transparency: The study demonstrates that deep learning models achieved high accuracy (92.11% for ResNet18) in classifying ancient ceramics, potentially reducing the time-intensive work of traditional petrographic analysis, while explainability techniques like Grad-CAM allowed researchers to verify that models were actually focusing on relevant mineralogical features rather than making "black box" decisions.
-
Explainability is essential for AI in specialized domains: By applying visualization techniques to show which features the neural networks used for classification, the researchers ensured that domain experts (archaeologists) could validate and trust the AI's reasoning, demonstrating that responsible AI implementation requires making model decisions interpretable to users, not just achieving high accuracy numbers.
-
Transfer learning enables AI with limited data: The models achieved strong performance using only 1,424 thin section images by leveraging pre-trained models, showing that responsible AI development doesn't always require massive datasets—strategic use of existing knowledge can make AI tools practical for specialized fields like archaeology that may have smaller data collections.
-
AI works best as a complementary tool, not a replacement: The paper frames deep learning as supporting rather than replacing traditional petrographic analysis, suggesting that responsible AI deployment in specialized fields should enhance human expertise rather than eliminate expert judgment from the decision-making process.